Skip to main content

Quick Review: The Giver

The Giver is an unarguably a classic piece of young adult literature. It is also something that has to be viewed through the lens of time to be properly enjoyed. Although I tried to see this as it probably was,  a transformative part of what we now know as YA, I was still ultimately unimpressed with the quality of writing and story. I was actually a little surprised by my dislike for "The Giver" as I am, after all, the target audience of the book. I read it for school, which may have contributed to some of my dislike of the book. (It's hard to enjoy something that you're being forced to read, and even harder so when you must dissect every line for quasi meaningful messages.) If you haven't heard of The Giver, it's about a boy named Jonas who lives in a perfect society.

My first issue with the book was my own description. (Lifted from the flap and online description.) By the end of the first chapter, it is painfully apparent that the society is not a utopia. Firstly, they don't use conjunctions. As we all know, a world without "conjunction junction" must be a dystopia. Seriously, though, that's one of my writing pet peeves.

My second issue was the lack of description. Although describing color is hard, I wish more of an effort had been put in. I didn't understand that there was no color in the world until I was three quarters of the way through it. I also felt like there wasn't enough description in general. We have no picture of Jonas' world, no way of comparing it to our own. (Visually, at least.)

Lastly, my real issue was Jonas himself. For someone supposed to be so perceptive, I found him quite stupid. Perhaps because I don't live in the giver's society, the meaning of 'release,' death, was very transparent to me. I don't see how he wouldn't at least have had questions about it. In addition, (Serious spoilers ahead) when the true nature of his family was revealed and his father was about to hurt Gabriel, his thought process was extremely convoluted. He immediately moves to save Gabe, not his equally innocent sister. Although she had been indoctrinated, Jonas not taking the medicine would make him able to feel love. I assume that he would love his sister, as is indicated by his love for his father. (Or at least respect/ trust that can be broken.) To me, it seems that the clear choice is to kidnap her. Of course, in my opinion, almost everyone in the society is innocent, having no way to see through societal constraints. It was annoying that he didn't even consider any of this before running away, and then regretted nothing. The ending was too open to be of much significance, although I've heard it was biblical which might be why I didn't grasp the meaning.

Overall, The Giver offers a sort of tired view on society with self insert characters (Although I would be distraught if I was Jonas.) and a pretty interesting plot that falls apart at the end.
2.5 stars.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

My Top 3 Tips for a Good Nanowrimo

Hey Everybody! Long time, no blog. I just wanted to log on super quickly to give y'all my top 3 Nanowrimo tips. So, just to start off, I am definitely not a good writer yet, nor am I claiming to be. However, I've done Nanowrimo for four years and have successfully completed it four times. (Some of those, I believe, were for camp.)  I have about 350,000 words written on my account and I actually used to have an old one that I've since lost. These tips are less about quality of work and more about getting words on the page. So, tip number one: Stay away from the wordcount box. Whenever I'm feeling like I don't want to write, I obsessively update my wordcount box. Literally. I will have 3450 and update and 3452. This is not a good writing habit, because it perpetuates a cycle of negative feelings. You don't feel good when you see that you've only written a hundred words. (If that's below your goal.) It traps you in seeing how little compared to...
Post a Comment
Read more

Quick review : With The Fire On High

Premise: "With the Fire on High" follows 17 year old Emoni as she enters her senior year of high school. The main challenges for Emoni are caring for her daughter, deciding what she wants to do in the future, and balancing a blossoming relationship. She lives with her grandmother, who she calls 'buela, and her two year old daughter, Emma. Her best friend is named Angelica, and she is flirting with a boy named Malachi. The story kicks off when she decides to take a culinary arts class at her school, although cooking was already a passion of hers.  Writing Style Although this lacked some of the outright lyricism of the Poet X, it was very readable. Emoni's voice was well developed, and the characters had compelling backstories and motivations. Although it was about four hundred pages, I read it very quickly.  Diversity Emoni is Puerto Rican and Black. Her best friend is a lesbian, and her love interest is also black.  The Best Parts Reading this book ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Popular Books I Didn't Like

Before you start reading, you might want to have a mop at the ready. There's going to be a lot of tea spilled. Now that we're over that uncomfortable segue, the way that I'm qualifying a  book as popular is if it has over 1,000 ratings on goodreads or the author has a different book with over 1,000. For me, disliking a book means I gave it one or two stars. 1. The Perks of Being a Wallflower by Stephen Chbosky This is a hard one to summarize. It's mainly about a kid named Charlie, who I think is about 14. It follows him through high school as he deals with growing up. I found Charlie, as a character, to be both immature and pretentious simultaneously. I could have dealt with one, but with both, he seemed to be more of a lens to portray the story then a person. In addition to that, many important issues were brought up and then dismissed. This could have been a lot longer and much better. 2. Sadie, by Courtney Summers The story follows a girl named Sadie whose...
Post a Comment
Read more